Each match is scored and averaged using our 5-Star STAR Rating system with a maximum possible score of 20

When two matches have the same score, a (*) denotes the match won the tie-breaker vote in a season finale episode

EPISODE NUMBER & MATCH Final Average Joaquin Frank Chuck Guest
S1E01 Hulk Hogan vs TheRock - WrestleMania X8 12.75 15.5 12 10 13.5
S1E02 Samoa Joe vs Kobashi Kenta - Ring of Honor (*) 13.875 14.5 16 12 13
S1E03 The Nasty Boys vs Cactus & Payne - Spring Stampede 1994 8.875 5.5 7.5 10 12.5
S1E04 CM Punk vs John Cena - WWE RAW 2/26/13 16 18 17.5 15 13.5
S1E05 RVD vs Jerry Lynn - Hardcore Heaven 99 10.5625 11.25 10 11 10
S1E06 The Undertaker vs Mankind - King of the Ring 1998 (*) 15.125 16.5 16 13 15
S1E07 Randy Savage vs The Ultimate Warrior - WrestleMania VII (*) 14.5 16.5 14 11.5 16
S1E08 Sasha Banks vs Bayley - NXT Takeover: Brooklyn (*) 15.75 16.5 16.5 16 14
S1E09 TLCII - WrestleMania X-7 12.25 15.5 13 11.5 9
S1E10 Ric Flair vs Sting - Clash of the Champions I 15.0625 14.75 14.5 16.5 14.5
S2E01 Shawn Michaels vs Razor Ramon - WrestleMania10 14.8125 15.75 15 12.5 16
S2E02 Misawa & Kobashi vs Kawada & Taue - AJPW 3/12/93 (*) 16 15 16 17.5 15.5
S2E03 AJ Styles vs Samoa Joe vs Christopher Daniels - TNA Unbreakable 2005 13.475 14.5 15 11 13.25
S2E04 Shinsuke Nakamura vs Sami Zayn - NXT Takeover: Dallas 15.687 16.5 16.75 15 14.5
S2E05 Tully Blanchard vs Magum TA - Starrcade 85 14.5 13.25 14 16 14.75
S2E06 Do Fixer vs Blood Generation - ROH Supercard of Honor 2006 12.125 13.25 12.25 10.5 12.5
S2E07 Tomoaki Honma vs Tomohiro Ishii - NJPW The New Beginning in Sendai 2005 13.25 14.75 15.25 12 11
S2E08 Steve Austin vs Dude Love - WWF Over the Edge 1998 15.875 15.5 15 16 17
S2E09 Eddy Guerrero vs Rey Misterio Jr - WCW Halloween Havoc 1997 15.4375 17.5 15 13.5 15.75
S2E10 Will Ospreay vs Jimmy Havoc - PROGRESS Wrestling CH. 20 12.625 14 12 12.5 12
S3E01 Bret Hart vs Owen Hart - WrestleMania X 16.1875 16.75 16 18 14
S3E02 DIY vs The Revival - NXT Takeover: Toronto 13.4375 16.5 14.5 14.25 8.5
S3E03 Ric Flair vs Dusty Rhodes - Starrcade 85 10.9375 12.25 11.5 9.5 10.5
S3E04 Triple H vs Batista - WWE Vengeance 2005 (*) 13.5 15.25 11.5 13.75 14
S3E05 Ricochet vs Will Ospreay - NJPW Best of the Super Juniors 2016 13.875 15.5 12 12 16
S3E06 Stan Hansen vs Dr. Death Steve Williams - AJPW 6/5/90 11.4375 12 12 10.5 11.25
S3E07 Chris Hero vs Tommy End - PWG Don't Sweat the Technique 15.125 16 16.25 16.25 12
S3E08 Ric Flair vs Shawn Michaels - WrestleMania 24 15.75 17.5 18 13 14.5
S3E09 Akira Hokuto vs Shinobu Kandori - AJW 4/2/93 13.375 14.75 14.5 14.5 9.75
S3E10 Kazuchika Okada vs Kenny Omega - NJPW Wrestle Kingdom 11 18.5 18 19.25 18.25 18.5
S4E01 Bret Hart vs Steve Austin - WrestleMania 13 18.125 19.25 16.75 18.5 18
S4E02 Royal Rumble 2008 7.625 11 8.5 5.5 5.5
S4E03 Katsuhiko Nakajima vs Brian Cage - Pro Wrestling NOAH 7/27/17 11.8125 12.25 12 11 12
S4E04 Rey Mysterio Jr vs Juventud Guerrera - ECW Big Ass Extreme Bash 3/9/96 13.5 13.5 11.25 12.5 16.75
S4E05 Nigel McGuinness vs Bryan Danielson - ROH Unified 13.5625 12.25 14.5 13.5 14
S4E06 The Undertaker vs Jeff Hardy - WWE RAW 7/1/02 16.25 15.75 16.25 16 17
S4E07 La Pareja Del Terror vs El Hijo Del Santo & Octagón - AAA/IWC 11/6/94 14.625 16.5 11.5 15.5 15
S4E08 The Young Bucks vs The World's Cutest Tag Team - PWG ELEVEN 13.625 14.5 14 13 13
S4E09 Brock Lesnar vs Seth Rollins vs John Cena - Royal Rumble 2015 13.3125 15 12 13.25 13
S4E10 Miyu Yamashita vs Meiko Satomura - Tokyo Joshi Pro 8/26/17 14.1875 14.75 14 15.5 12.5